Imagine you’re up for a promotion at work. You’ve put in the hours, delivered great results, and feel like you have a solid shot. Then, you find out that the promotion went to someone else. Disappointing, right? But what if you also learn that the decision was made behind closed doors, with no clear criteria, and that leadership played favorites? Now you’re not just disappointed — you’re outraged.

That feeling — that deep frustration when a process feels unfair — is exactly what procedural justice is about. It’s not just the outcome that matters to people, but how decisions are made. Research has shown time and again that employees will accept even unfavorable outcomes if they believe the process used to arrive at those decisions was fair. In this post, we’ll explore why procedural justice matters in the workplace, what the research says about it, and how companies can build trust by ensuring fair processes.

What is procedural justice?

Procedural justice is a concept from organizational psychology and legal studies that refers to the perceived fairness of the processes that lead to decisions. It was popularized by psychologist John Thibaut and sociologist Laurens Walker in the 1970s, who found that people care deeply about how decisions are made, sometimes even more than the outcomes themselves.

In the workplace, procedural justice is about things like:

  • Transparency: Are employees aware of how decisions are made?
  • Consistency: Are the same standards applied to everyone?
  • Voice: Do employees have an opportunity to share their perspectives?
  • Accuracy: Are decisions based on complete and reliable information?
  • Correctability: Is there a process for appealing or questioning decisions?
  • Ethicality: Are the decision-makers acting in a way that aligns with moral and organizational values?

When these elements are present, employees are far more likely to accept outcomes, even if those outcomes aren’t in their favor.


Sample Ethena's Ethical Management training

People care more about fairness than winning, research shows

Lind and Tyler’s Study on Fairness Perceptions

One of the most influential studies on procedural justice comes from Tom Tyler and Allan Lind. Their research found that people who perceive decision-making procedures as fair are more likely to accept even negative outcomes without resentment. Employees are less likely to engage in counterproductive behaviors, like reducing effort, disengaging, or even quitting, if they believe their employer treated them fairly in the decision-making process.

The “Fair Process Effect” in Organizations

A 2001 study by Brockner and colleagues explored what they called the "fair process effect." They found that when employees felt involved in decisions and believed the process was fair, they were more committed to their jobs — even if the final decision wasn’t what they wanted. In contrast, when processes were perceived as unfair, employees reacted negatively, even when outcomes were favorable.

The Role of Procedural Justice in Layoffs

A fascinating application of procedural justice research comes from studies on corporate downsizing. Greenberg (1990) found that companies that provided employees with clear explanations, advanced notice, and severance support during layoffs saw significantly lower rates of theft, absenteeism, and retaliation compared to companies that handled layoffs in a secretive, arbitrary, or disrespectful manner.

Why does procedural justice matter in the workplace?

1. It builds trust in management and leadership

Employees who believe their leaders make decisions fairly are more likely to trust them. And trust, as any leader knows, is the foundation of a productive, engaged workforce.

2. It reduces legal risk and workplace conflict

Many workplace disputes, including discrimination claims, grievances, and lawsuits, arise not just because of the outcome but because employees felt the process was unjust. Ensuring procedural fairness can help prevent costly conflicts and reputational damage.

3. It enhances employee engagement and morale

Research consistently shows that employees who feel heard and respected are more engaged. They’re more willing to put in discretionary effort and go above and beyond in their roles.

4. It strengthens organizational culture

A commitment to fair processes signals to employees that the organization values integrity, transparency, and respect. This can shape a more ethical and collaborative workplace culture.

How to improve procedural justice in your organization

If you want to create a workplace where employees feel decisions are made fairly, consider these steps:

1. Be transparent about decision-making

Employees don’t expect to get their way all the time, but they do expect honesty. Whether it’s about promotions, pay decisions, or company policies, communicate how and why decisions are made.

2. Give employees a voice

People are more likely to accept outcomes — even unfavorable ones — if they feel they had a chance to be heard. This could be through town halls, employee surveys, one-on-one meetings, or open-door policies.

3. Apply consistent standards

Favoritism and inconsistency are fairness killers. Make sure policies and decision criteria are applied consistently across employees, departments, and situations.

4. Provide an appeal or feedback mechanism

If employees feel a decision was incorrect or unfair, they should have a way to challenge it. Establish a clear and accessible grievance or appeal process.

5. Train managers on ethical workplace behavioral

Many fairness violations happen at the manager level, often unintentionally. Invest in training managers on how to make decisions transparently, involve employees in the process, and communicate decisions effectively.

6. Treat employees with respect, even in tough situations

Whether it’s delivering bad news about a layoff, denying a raise, or rejecting a project proposal, the way you communicate matters. A respectful, empathetic approach makes a world of difference.

The bottom line

Procedural justice isn’t just an abstract theory — it’s a fundamental part of workplace fairness. Employees don’t just want good outcomes; they want to know that decisions affecting them are made in a fair, transparent, and respectful manner. When organizations get this right, they build trust, reduce turnover, prevent legal issues, and create a more engaged workforce.

If your company is struggling with employee morale, turnover, or engagement, take a closer look at your processes. Are they clear? Are they consistent? Do employees feel heard? The answers to these questions could be the key to unlocking a stronger, more committed workforce.